Jason Kelce’s Former Teammate Reacts to Kylie Kelce Mix

Kylie and Jason took their daughters Wyatt and Elliotte to see Taylor Swift’s Miami concert on Oct. 18

Beau Allen and Kylie Kelce attend Taylor Swift’s Eras Tour in Miami. Photo: Beau Allen/Instagram

Kylie Kelce has a surprising new doppëlganger.

When Kylie and her husband Jason Kelce took their daughters Wyatt, 5, and Elliotte, 3, to see Taylor Swift in concert in Miami, fans were eager to catch a glimpse of the former NFL star and his family supporting Swift, 34.

But one fan’s excitement led to a hilarious viral mixup when Jason’s former Philadelphia Eagles teammate Beau Allen was mistaken for Kylie.

In a fan-taken photo, Allen, 32, is excitedly pumping his fists into the air during the show at Hard Rock Stadium. The former NFL tackle was sporting a cowboy hat over his long locks for the show, with a matching denim ensemble.

Because he appeared to be moving when the photo was taken, Allen’s face is slightly blurred, likely leading to the quick mixup.

Beau Allen attends the Eras Tour in Miami. Beau Allen/Instagram

Still, social media couldn’t let the hilarious mixup slide when screenshots of the comment were uploaded to X (formerly known as Twitter).

As seen in the uploaded screenshot, the viral comment said, “Kylie is so beautiful, down to earth, looks at those ripped field hockey arms…she is the glue, the neck, the foundation, Kylie is giving us Midwestern Moms life!!”

When another user asked where the commenter had spotted Kylie’s arms in the image, the confused fan replied, “Isn’t that her dancing around Jason in the cowboy hat?? Look at those guns!!”

Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE’s free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from juicy celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

Kylie and Allen put their look-a-like rumors to rest at the show when Allen shared a photo with a smiling Kylie. “Miss Americana and the Heartbreak Prince,” Allen cheekily wrote in the caption.

Beau Allen and Kylie Kelce. Beau Allen/Instagram

And on a new live episode ofGreen Light, his podcast co-hosted by Chris Long and Nate Collins, posted Tuesday, Oct. 22, Allen poked fun at the mixup. “I was mistaken for the lovely Kylie Kelce at the [Taylor] Swift concert, which I’m rocking my merch for today,” Allen said on the show.

“T. Swift kind of popped off, but someone said that she thought I was Kylie, dancing with Jason,” he continued, specifically referencing the comment’s mention of Kylie appearing “down to earth” and the suggestion to “look at those ripped field hockey arms.”

“She is the glue, the neck, the foundation,” Allen recited from the comment.

“That sh– was so funny to me,” Jones said of the mistake. “I mean that is solid gold. And what’s even better is that you commented underneath.”

Allen replied to the posted screenshots, joking, “She wishes she had this ass.”

The Oct. 18 show marked the first time Jason and Travis’ mom, Donna Kelce, attended one of Swift’s concerts. In a video posted on TikTok by a fan at the show, the Kelce crew can be seen walking around the stadium among fellow Swifties.